Problem
A team ships an LLM feature, and the user sees a fluent answer with no hint of its reliability. A confident error can cost more than no answer. With classifiers, confidence is the max class probability. For generated text it is ambiguous: an answer can be partly right, and its probability depends on length, wording and synonyms. The team needs a separate layer that scores risk and decides whether to show, verify or withhold the answer.
Illustrative example: a support bot answers "the refund window is 30 days" when the policy says 14. A risk score on that claim would send it to a check instead of the customer.
Solution in brief
Put an estimator, a policy layer and a monitoring loop around the LLM. The estimator turns signals (token probabilities, agreement between several samples, claim-level scores) into a risk score, and the policy compares it with a threshold to show, verify or abstain. Before deployment, check ranking quality, the rejection curve, calibration and product metrics.
Questions this case answers
- How to decide when a generative model should abstain instead of giving a plausible but risky answer
- How to choose an abstention threshold and evaluate a risk score for generated answers before deployment
- How to decide when an LLM should abstain instead of giving a plausible but risky answer
- How to estimate whether an LLM answer is likely to be wrong
Tools and methods
- LM-Polygraph — open-source library with 40+ uncertainty methods behind one API, for white-box and black-box models
- Token probabilities — logprobs, perplexity, per-token entropy
- Semantic entropy, self-consistency — uncertainty from several sampled answers
- Claim-Conditioned Probability — risk score for a single claim in the answer
- PRR, rejection curve, ECE — evaluation of an uncertainty score
Google or a one-time email code. No password.