Problem
Square sells more than 35 products to sellers. Each product has its own success metrics, such as free trial starts or the first revenue event. Shared spaces work differently: the public website, the general signup flow and the seller dashboard serve all products at once. A change there, for example which products onboarding suggests first, helps one product and may hurt another. Teams need a criterion for these tradeoffs and a way to measure a change across the whole ecosystem.
Example from the article: during onboarding Square can suggest certain products over others, and it has to decide how to prioritize them.
Solution in brief
The post compares six ways to set a success metric for shared surfaces and lists pros and cons of each. No option wins outright, and the author says metrics do not replace strategy.
Questions this case answers
- How to choose a single success metric for a surface shared by several products whose value and ramp-up time differ and whose goals trade off
- How to balance a fast, observable proxy against a slow, noisy long-term value target when deciding experiments
- How to choose one success metric for a shared surface (signup flow, website, dashboard) when many products compete for the same seller?
- How to decide which product to promote during onboarding when products differ in size, ramp-up time and revenue?
Tools and methods
- No standardized policy — case-by-case metric per experiment
- Revenue or gross profit with a cutoff — product-indifferent, actual money
- LTV forecasting model — predicted long-term value as the target
- Product tiers — leadership ranks products
- Early event x value estimate — adoption event multiplied by a hard-coded value
- Product-specific metric — one adoption, engagement or churn event
Google or a one-time email code. No password.